Report on Water in Flint: DNA Markers for Legionella Decreasing, But Vigilance Urged

Microbial water quality issues of Flint drinking water are improving, based on recent testing in March 2016, but that continued vigilance is in order, according to data presented at ASM Microbe 2016.

The research, performed by the Flint Water Study team at Virginia Tech, found that levels of DNA markers for Legionella have decreased throughout Flint since October 2015 before the water change, but did confirm that pathogenic forms of the bacteria, including L. pneumophila, were culturable at some sampling points.

A decision made in April 2014 to change the drinking water source for Flint, MI, to the highly corrosive Flint River led to wide-spread corrosion and infrastructure damage throughout the water distribution system.  In addition to increased incidence of elevated blood lead levels in children, two major clusters of Legionnaires’ disease occurred in the summers following the water switch, with 91 reported cases and 12 confirmed deaths to date.  

Since October 2015, the drinking water distribution system has been returned to its original source (City of Detroit water) and a corrosion control plan is now in place, with water quality improving slowly but steadily. Residents are advised to continue using bottled water or a filter certified to remove lead when using water for drinking or cooking. 

Recent testing of Flint drinking water in March 2016 indicates that the water quality is improving, but low water usage, which increases the age (ie, stagnation time) of water drawn at the tap, has made the recovery slower than we had hoped,” Otto Schwake, research scientist, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Virginia Tech, said in a press release about the study.  “To help remedy this, a program that allowed free water to residents to clean out pipes by flushing was implemented in May, supported by the State of Michigan and EPA, which should have improved the situation further.”

“Our city-wide monitoring of Legionella DNA markers has indicated improvement, but in the latest analysis we were able to also culture Legionella and confirmed L. pneumophila Serogroup 1, the most common culprit in Legionnaires’ disease, to be viable at some sampling locations in large buildings.  Since Legionnaires’ disease is more common in warm seasons, it will be important to continue monitoring through summer and for the medical community to be vigilant in diagnosing pneumonia cases,” said Dr Schwake. 

Three field samplings for this ongoing project have occurred to date, August 2015, October 2015 (immediately before the switch back to the City of Detroit Water), and March 2016.   “We previously only targeted Legionella DNA, which, while highly accurate, fails to distinguish between live and dead cells.  After processing water samples from March, we now have a large collection  of cultured environmental samples and Legionella isolates from Flint, which could prove useful in tracking the transmission of Legionnaires’ in the city,” said Dr Schwake. An additional trip is planned for summer 2016 to test the hypothesis that Legionella levels should not rise back to levels encountered during the 2015 outbreak, due to the change in water source, higher chlorine residuals, lower temperatures, and optimized corrosion control.

Reference

Schwake DO. Garner E, Strom O, et al. Lapse in Municipal Water Corrosion Control Linked to Elevated Legionella Levels in Building Plumbing. Poster 124. Presented at: ASM Microbe 2016. June 17-20, 2016. Boston.